Can suppressing unwanted thoughts be good for your mental health?

Consider campaigns you have seen which aim to reduce male suicide. Many of the messages they promote are shaped by commonly held views about men and their mental health.[1,2,3] With good intentions these are shared across social media.

But do we stop to question whether these messages are helpful? Do we ask if they are informed by research? Or do they promote assumptions rooted in politicised views about gender? Might they even be red herrings which get in the way of addressing issues which can contribute to male suicide?

Whether messages are at best well-meaning expressions, or at worst holding back wider understanding, it’s worth pausing to ask: should we reshare them, or are they red herrings?

Putting the brakes on

A common assumption about emotions is that suppressing them is unhealthy. We hear that men are at increased risk of suicide when they ‘bottle up’ feelings.  Related to this is the belief that ‘toxic masculinity’ has conditioned men to suppress emotions and that this conditioning must be undone.4

 

“Is the claim that it is harmful to supress emotions supported by evidence? Or does it reflect a gendered view of mental health?”

 

But do these beliefs oversimplify how emotions function? Is the claim that it is harmful to supress emotions supported by evidence? Or does it reflect a gendered view of mental health?

Think of a time when a close friend or relative shared their distress with you. You could see clearly their distress was caused by a mistake they had made. Not only that, but this was the umpteenth time they had made the mistake with the same painful result.

Maybe they had rushed into a romance too soon, only for it not to work out. Maybe they had rekindled a friendship or relationship or put their trust in someone who had treated them badly in the past. Maybe they had fallen for a scam or lent money from their savings, only to lose it again.

Whatever the situation was, you could see that they had not learnt from previous experiences. But did you jump at the opportunity to point this out? Or vent your frustrations at them for failing to learn? Probably not.

It’s likely that you could see that it wasn’t the right time to express your emotions. You could see that what your friend or relative needed at that time was a listening and sympathetic ear. You would have intuited that lecturing them on their reoccurring mistakes would not have landed well. It might even have worsened their distress. This was not the right time, so you put the brakes on.

 

“…whatever your gender, putting the brakes on emotions is an essential skill.”

 

In everyday life, we supress emotions all the time. We might be shopping and see food which arouses a desire for a tasty treat to lift our mood. But if we consider first whether it is healthy we are suppressing emotions. If we see adverts for clothing we feel which might improve our appearance, but prioritise sticking to our budget, we are suppressing emotions.

It may be necessary to do this with every decision we make, and it is not inherently unhealthy. On the contrary, meeting needs in healthy ways requires suppressing impulsivity and unhealthy desires.

This doesn't mean that problems should be left unaddressed and ignored. Stress, distress, anxiety and fears are nature’s way of telling us that needs are unmet and should be given attention. But that does not mean that expressing emotions is the solution.

In fact, whatever your gender, putting the brakes on emotions is an essential skill. And for men who are good at this, it might be more helpful to celebrate the ability to suppress inappropriate emotions. We can then recognise that emotional suppression is not a deficit. In fact, it is an essential first step toward solving problems, with the right support.   

 

Taking things to heart

Another belief about suppressing emotions, rooted in established schools of psychotherapy, holds that suppressing anger is bad for us. Those people who make this claim point to increases in blood pressure when we suppress anger.

They reason that the expression of anger is good for cardiovascular health because it reduces blood pressure. Researchers examining the evidence for this belief, however, came to a different conclusion.

 

“…angry impulses can be reframed to take into consideration the needs of others. To reframe and consider the needs of others, angry reactions need to be suppressed.”

 

Further investigation found that venting anger increased the likelihood of reacting with anger to future events. In other words, practising angry responses makes us more likely to react to situations with anger.[5] It was the increased expression of anger, not suppressing anger, which resulted in unhealthy increases blood pressure.  

Other cultural differences point to nuances around the expression of anger. One study measured blood pressure in two groups after provoking anger in a role play exercise.[6] Participants were instructed to either suppress, express or to reconsider and reframe their angry responses.

The first group in the study were north American Caucasians. Regardless of whether they suppressed, expressed or tried to reframe their angry responses, this group showed increased blood pressure, consistent with previous studies.

The second group, however, showed a reduction in blood pressure when provoked. This group were Chinese. The study concluded that the Chinese participants seemed better able to reframe their anger. But why?

One speculation is that Chinese culture prioritises community cohesion over individual needs, rewarding people with a sense of harmony when they do so. These studies demonstrate that angry impulses can be reframed to take into consideration the needs of others.[7]

To reframe and consider the needs of others, angry reactions need to be suppressed. Could this be a skill that many men already draw upon in their working lives?

If we think of those working in emergency services – like those responding to fires – they need to suppress emotional responses to danger, in order to save the lives of others. Again, their ability to suppress emotions as the first step to solving a problem, is not a deficit, but an essential skill.      

 

For crying out loud

Another widely held belief about the expression of emotion is the myth that crying is cathartic. Some people even argue that if men would only learn to cry more often, it would improve their mental health and reduce suicide rates.

In 2019, the World Economic Forum went so far as to launch a video promoting crying as an effective stress management intervention. The video pointed to Japan as an example of good practice, where, to reduce death from work related stress and suicide ‘crying teachers’ were sent into workplaces to instruct people – men and women – to cry at least once a week. [8]

The video did not mention whether other factors, like long working hours, micromanaging or bullying would be addressed. Nor did they include any evaluation of whether the crying teachers had made a positive difference to suicide rates.   

Does research support the claim that crying more often would reduce stress and, potentially, male suicide rates? Having read the research around the effects and evolution of crying, I wanted to check my understanding.

I reached out to Ad Vingerhoets, a Professor of Clinical Psychology and one of the world’s leading researchers on the evolution and function of crying. Professor Vingerhoets explained that the evidence pointed to the primary function of crying being to signal distress to caregivers. It is significant that crying is a visual signal, because human social groups can be made up of large numbers. 9

 

“For people already struggling with poor mental health, their mental health may worsen following crying.”

 

But what if someone is socially isolated and there is nobody to respond to their distress? Would crying have a cathartic effect and reduce their distress? Vingerhoets explained that to answer this question, researchers measure mental wellbeing before and after crying episodes. This is necessary to test subjective claims that people feel better after crying.

What researchers have consistently found is that mental wellbeing before crying predicts how we will feel after crying. So, assuming someone is reasonably emotionally healthy, but then something happens which they feel little control over. Perhaps they witness someone else in pain or are reminded of a painful event from the past. The research found that if they cry in response to the event, once the crying ends, their wellbeing will return to where it was before the event. The same is true for people with average measures of wellbeing. [10,11]       

But what about people who are already have poor mental health? What happens if they cry in response to a painful event? For people already struggling with poor mental health, their mental health may worsen following crying. This is particularly the case if their crying is prolonged and they cry repeatedly. [12]

A further complication is that crying can take different forms. For instance, we might shed tears of joy, sentimental tears in response to music, a book or a film, or crying when we feel empathy or connection to people. [9]

So currently, research does not support the belief that crying is good for mental health. And, given that crying is most commonly caused by feelings of helplessness and loss of hope – feelings which frequently accompany heightened suicide risk – promoting crying as a solution seems misguided. [12]   

 

Where is a village when you need one?

These beliefs, that men shouldn’t suppress emotions, that they should learn to express them openly, and that they need to cry more often, are not just at odds with the evidence from research into emotion: they reflect a deficit-based view of how men experience emotions.13 They also impose this view on people who are already struggling with thoughts of suicide and the life events which cause them.

Imagine adopting the same approach to people experiencing other causes of distress. What if survivors of violence struggled to sleep because of flashbacks and intrusive memories of the event? Would we tell them just to turn the lights out and close their eyes?

What if someone has come to rely upon cannabis to cope with the symptoms of schizophrenia and offset the side effects of antipsychotic medication? Should a mental health professional tell them to prioritise quitting cannabis use? Would we ask a survivor of domestic abuse, ‘Why didn’t you just leave?’

These kinds of responses all reduce the suffers difficulties to a matter of personal responsibility. And yet suicide prevention campaigns do exactly this when they tell men that how they process emotions is the cause of their problems.

It is not always obvious when people are struggling with issues, or with thoughts of suicide. But instead of placing the burden and sole responsibility on men who are already overwhelmed, could we take responsibility and ask them directly, ‘are you having thoughts of suicide?’ It might be uncomfortable. But by doing so, we might save a life.

 

References

1.    Margot C.A. van der Burgt, Aartjan T.F. Beekman, Adriaan W. Hoogendoorn, Guus Berkelmans, Gerdien Franx, Renske Gilissen, (2021) The impact of a suicide prevention awareness campaign on stigma, taboo and attitudes towards professional help-seeking, Journal of Affective Disorders, Volume 279, Pages 730-736, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jad.2020.11.024.

2.    Scotti Requena, S., Pirkis, J., Currier, D., Conway, M., Lee, S., Turnure, J., Cummins, J., & Nicholas, A. (2023). An Evaluation of the Boys Do Cry Suicide Prevention Media Campaign on Twitter: Mixed Methods Approach. JMIR formative research, 7, e49325. https://doi.org/10.2196/49325

3.    Bennett, S., Robb, K.A. & O’Connor, R.C. “Male suicide and barriers to accessing professional support: a qualitative thematic analysis”. Curr Psychol 43, 15125–15145 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12144-023-05423-1

4.    https://www.apa.org/about/policy/boys-men-practice-guidelines.pdf?ref=quillette.com

5.    Bushman, B. J. (2002). Does Venting Anger Feed or Extinguish the Flame? Catharsis, Rumination, Distraction, Anger, and Aggressive Responding. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 28(6), 724-731. https://doi.org/10.1177/0146167202289002

6.    Zhou, T., Bishop, G. D. (2012) Culture moderates the cardiovascular consequences of anger regulation strategy. International Journal of Psychophysiology. Pages: 291-298. Volume: Volume 86, Issue 3. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijpsycho.2012.10.010

7.    Gross, J. J. (2015). Emotion Regulation: Current Status and Future Prospects. Psychological Inquiry, 26(1), 1–26. https://doi.org/10.1080/1047840X.2014.940781

8.    https://www.weforum.org/stories/wellbeing-and-mental-health/how-crying-once-a-week-is-the-key-to-a-stress-free-life-according-to-japan-s-tears-teacher

9.    Vingerhoets, A. J. J. M., & Bylsma, L. M. (2016). The Riddle of Human Emotional Crying: A Challenge for Emotion Researchers. Emotion review : journal of the International Society for Research on Emotion, 8(3), 207–217. https://doi.org/10.1177/1754073915586226

10. Bylsma, L. M., Vingerhoets, A. J., & Rottenberg, J. (2008) When is Crying Cathartic? An International Study. Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology 2008 27:10, 1165-1187 10.1521/jscp.2008.27.10.1165

11. Bylsma, L., Croon, M. A., Vingerhoets, A. J. J. M., & Rottenberg, J. (2011). When and for whom does crying improve mood? A daily diary study of 1004 crying episodes. Journal of Research in Personality, 45(4), 385-392. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jrp.2011.04.007

12. Gračanin, A., Vingerhoets, A.J.J.M., Kardum, I. et al. (2015) Why crying does and sometimes does not seem to alleviate mood: a quasi-experimental study. Motiv Emot 39, 953–960. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11031-015-9507-9

13. Barry, J. (2025) Building a healthier future for men’s mental health: The case for male centred therapy. https://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/id/eprint/10216518/1/Male-centred%20therapy%20-%20John%20Barry%20Oct%202025.pdf

Scroll down to the comments section to join the discussion


Disclaimer: This article is for information purposes only and is not a substitute for therapy, legal advice, or other professional opinion. Never disregard such advice because of this article or anything else you have read from the Centre for Male Psychology. The views expressed here do not necessarily reflect those of, or are endorsed by, The Centre for Male Psychology, and we cannot be held responsible for these views. Read our full disclaimer here.


Like our articles?
Click here to subscribe to our FREE newsletter and be first
to hear about news, events, and publications.



Have you got something to say?
Check out our submissions page to find out how to write for us.


.

John Barry

Dr John Barry is a chartered psychologist, researcher, clinical hypnotherapist and co-founder of the Male Psychology Network, BPS Male Psychology Section, and The Centre for Male Psychology (CMP). Also co-editor of the Palgrave Handbook of Male Psychology & Mental Health, co-author of the textbook Perspectives in Male Psychology: An Introduction (Wiley), and presenter on Centre for Male Psychology training courses.

Previous
Previous

Landmark research study finds clear evidence of pro-women/anti-men bias

Next
Next

Why does men’s mental health get less recognition than women’s mental health? A letter to the Canadian Mental Health Commission Hamilton.